Article Image

IPFS News Link • China

Why the Warmongers Are Wrong About China

• LewRockwell.com - Lew Rockwell

In an earlier article, "No War with China," I discussed the plans of braindead Biden and the neocon gang that controls him to start a war with China. This of course would be a disaster, but it leads to another question I'd like to talk about this week. Do we have to quarrel with China at all? Why can't we have peaceful, friendly relations with China? The warmongers say otherwise; let's look at some of their so-called "arguments."

One of them is that the Chinese state suppresses dissent and keeps people under surveillance. This is true, but why is this a reason to go war, and who are we to talk? As Harvard history professor James Hankins points out, "Our educated elites have largely abandoned their country's traditional advocacy of free speech, free exercise of religion, and private property. Woke leftists embedded in universities, large corporations, and professional societies are now determined to brand our country as 'structurally racist,' offering up declarations of guilt that CCP propagandists have seized upon with glee. They are bent on establishing a form of ideological tyranny that resembles Mao's Cultural Revolution, which even the CCP has repudiated. In that context, to deploy the standard U.S. weapon of attacking China for its violations of human rights will hardly seem other than absurdly hypocritical. The Left and the Democratic Party can be counted on to continue their assaults on capitalism—an aspect of American culture genuinely admired by Asians—and to advocate radical experiments in sexuality and family life—a side of American culture that the vast majority of Asians find embarrassing or repulsive."

Another argument that China is our enemy is that we have an unfavorable balance of trade with China. Chinese dumping takes away jobs from American workers, and the Chinese don't respect American IP rights. As always with the neocon warmongers, their "argument" reverses the truth, and these "former" Trotskyites echo Leftist bromides. As the great Murray Rothbard said, "First, of course, there is economics, never the . . .left's strong suit. While [William A.] Williams certainly uncovered an important cause of American imperialism in the continuing drive to subsidize American exports, he unfortunately also contributed the egregious misconception of 'free-trade imperialism.' In this view, free trade is just another variant of imperialism, less messy perhaps but just as effectively imperialist as colonial conquest or the neocolonialist blend of political pressure, undercover intrigue, and economic aid. It seems impossible for socialists to understand the peaceable and mutually beneficial nature of free markets and free trade. Sir Norman Angell and other nineteenth-century liberals may have been overoptimistic in their paeans to the peaceful influence of free trade, but they grasped a vitally important point. The old motto 'If Goods Can't Cross Borders, Troops Will' still makes sense."


Home Grown Food